Alternate page with proper canonical tag: when it’s fine and when it isn’t
“Alternate page with proper canonical tag” means Search Console marks this URL as an alternate of another page, and the page it points to is indexed. Google says there is nothing you need to do. It is a problem only if this URL is one you want on Google, or the canonical points to the wrong page.
When it's fine
Google's help page gives AMP, mobile and desktop versions of one page as its examples and says there is nothing you need to do. Parameter URLs that point to their main page are a common case on many sites, though Google's page does not list them:
- Tracking and sorting parameters:
/shop?utm_source=newsletter,/shop?sort=price - Product variants set with an optional query parameter (for example
/t-shirt?color=green) that point to the base product page - AMP versions of a page
Google says each page in a paginated sequence should have its own canonical, not point to page one.
When it's a problem
- The main page points away from itself. A template bug (every page canonical to the home page), or a page created by copying another one and keeping its canonical.
- The canonical points to staging or an old domain, for example
<link rel="canonical" href="https://staging.example.com/pricing"> - The canonical target is broken: it returns a 404 or an error. You're pointing Google at a URL that doesn't work, and Google may ignore the tag and pick a different canonical.
- Mixed signals: the page is set to noindex and has a canonical pointing to another URL. Google says noindex blocks a page completely from Search and is not the way to choose a canonical; the canonical tag is.
How to check the canonical and where it leads
View Source and search for canonical to see what the page declares. What View Source can't tell you is whether the URL it points to actually works. The checker below reads the canonical tag (and flags a missing one, several conflicting ones, or an invalid URL), tells you whether it points to this page or another one, and then fetches the target to see whether it returns 200, redirects, or fails.
How to fix it
- On a page that should be indexed: make its canonical point to itself, as an absolute URL written the way you want it indexed. Google treats URLs that differ by a trailing slash or by upper and lower case as different URLs:
<link rel="canonical" href="https://www.example.com/pricing"> - Template or plugin bug: fix it in the template or SEO plugin so every page outputs its own URL, rather than patching pages one by one.
- Broken target: point the canonical at the URL that actually serves the content, not at one that redirects.
- noindex plus canonical: decide which you mean. To consolidate a duplicate, keep the canonical and remove noindex. To keep a page out of search, use noindex and drop the canonical.
How to confirm the fix
Run the check again; for a page that should be indexed it should say the canonical target is this page and returns 200. Then, in Search Console's URL Inspection, compare User-declared canonical with Google-selected canonical. Google treats the canonical tag as a strong hint, not a command: if the two still differ after Google recrawls, Google is weighing other signals, such as near-identical content, redirects or which URL your internal links use. That case appears as a separate status, “Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user”.
If the page is correct and still missing, work through why a page isn't showing up on Google.
Sources
We read these official pages on 2026-10-13.
- Page indexing report - Search Console Help
- How to Specify a Canonical with rel="canonical" and Other Methods (page dated 2026-07-10)
- What is URL Canonicalization (page dated 2026-08-20)
- Fix Canonicalization Issues (page dated 2026-08-21)
- URL Inspection tool - Search Console Help
- Pagination Best Practices for Google (page dated 2025-12-10)
- Ecommerce URL Structure Best Practices (page dated 2025-12-10)
- Block Search Indexing with noindex (page dated 2025-12-10)
- URL Structure Best Practices for Google Search (page dated 2025-12-10)
- To slash or not to slash - Google Search Central Blog (page dated 2010-04-21)
Fixed this one? Before you send people to the page, run the full pre-publish check for everything else: indexing signals, link preview, broken links, alt text, structured data and HTTPS in one pass.